If we are to aspire to redistribution ...we should realize it does not work.

There is no way we can distribute equally ...and to call for redistribution, is really calling to do exactly that.  It is calling to move it from one place to another.

What people could say is that they want equal distribution ...not redistribution.  And maybe that is what they are asking for ...but should realize that is also not possible.  The reasons I've already given are well-evidenced in our world, where we are not always wise stewards of what we have.